Jigsaw Puzzle stuff again
May. 17th, 2012 11:28 pmI've been doing jigsaws at a ridiculous pace recently, and that seems to be my current obsession. This is a post I've been working here and there for a few days now. Lots of puzzle recs and notes down below.
From my previous post, since I'm using this terminology below:
Piece Shape: I consider the most "Basic" piece shape to be the traditional "two tabs opposite each other" that we tend to imagine as a default. Some puzzles have nothing but these (and are damned hard as a result!) Most, though, have what I'm calling "Standard Varied" shapes -- they're still basically meant to fit within a grid, and have four sides with pretty clear innies and outies in various combinations. That leads to six basic piece shapes, if I'm counting correctly. When I'm working with these kinds of puzzles I tend to sort them first by basic piece shape. Then there are puzzles with "Unusual Varied" pieces that don't fit this basic format, and puzzles with some "Representational" pieces (known as Whimsies in the puzzling world). In my tracking of my puzzles I'm using "Basic/Standard Varied/Unusual Varied/Representational" as my categories.
I'm thinking about and window-shopping puzzles largely because it's hard to sort the wheat from the chaff in finding good puzzles without knowing something about their piece shape and arrangement (since that's a big factor of the enjoyment). It's frustrating to buy an awesome-looking puzzle and discover that it's entirely composed of Basic pieces. Very rarely is this clarified on puzzle-selling sites, so instead I try to take note of which manufacturers use creative dies, and which manufacturers tend to use the kinds of images I enjoy most. Even though specific puzzles below may no longer be available (they tend to go "out of print" quickly), I'll still be better off in finding good stuff overall.
On the puzzle front, I also forgot the other day to note one of the central things I enjoy about doing jigsaw puzzles! I really love the process of having to study a single image so closely and for so long; it gives me practice looking at things in different ways, noting their tiny characteristics, things like that. And I've always been particularly good at most spatial stuff, so I enjoy that element of mentally rotating and matching.
My favorite are puzzles with a lot of intricate detail; I don't like the long slog of trying piece after identical piece in a spot (the worst was a 1000-piece map of the world where the entire ocean was the same exact shade of blue and there was almost no piece shape differentiation). I much prefer having to think more intensely about what that little detail might be, and where it might logically fit. My favorites in that regard are the series of shaped puzzles with all sorts of little thematic details within them.
I just did Hummingbird Garden (Bits & Pieces) yesterday and enjoyed it immensely. Along with the fun detail and shape, it had lots of interesting piece shapes, too, and is a good example of my favorite type of puzzle, as is this Russian Dancer (another one I've done -- I believe it's Bits & Pieces too, although it's out of print).
Fionavar Tapestry Jigsaw Puzzle -- This is one I really enjoyed and found substantially challenging, although I'm not entirely positive I still have it. Sadly, it's also out of print, and I can't find any info on the manufacturer.
A comment from a post long ago, last time I got all puzzle-obsessed: I'm really liking Educa's puzzles, and that they have a lost piece service, and even include a packet of puzzle glue in the box, although I wish they were more creative with piece shape. Ah well; can't have it all.
Puzzle Manufacturers:
This isn't any kind of exhaustive list, just some notes about those I'm aware of, and what I know about them so far:
Bits & Pieces: From the colorful printing to the ultra heavy weight board, to the two piece presentation box, we make our puzzles to the highest standards. We design random cutting dies for more interesting puzzle pieces and rotate the dies to minimize duplication from puzzle to puzzle. -- They're not lying. I love their stuff when I can find images I like. Too bad they seem to mostly do country/nostalgia/cheesy stuff.
Here are a few I find interesting:
Bits & Pieces: Set Of 2 : Comic Chaos 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzles Len Epstein 20x27 Rectangular
Bits & Pieces: Black Bear Mountain 750 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Jack Williams 25x25 Shaped
Bits & Pieces: Wandering From The Den Skunk 750 Piece Shaped Jigsaw Puzzle Russell Cobane 20x27 (all of these shaped animal puzzles are pretty cheesy, but I'll suck it up when it's for my favorite sorts of animals)
Maybe surprisingly I'm not all that fond of Photomosaic jigsaws. I dislike the disconnect between the tiny images I'm trying to match to each other and the overall image itself.
Eurographics
Amazing cosmological, scientific, and artistic puzzle images. Unfortunately, I don't currently know anything about their piece shapes and cuts. Their puzzles also tend toward lots of small items against a solid background, which isn't my ideal sort of image, but on the flip side, those small items are often things like bats and inventors and spiders and musical instruments! If they turn out to have good piece shapes I might as well order stock in the damned company, but if they're boring shapes I'll be much less interested in the future.
Buffalo Games
PhotoSeek 750 Piece Rectangular Puzzles
Side by side they look the same, but look again! The image on the package and the fold out poster have 15 differences from the actual puzzle image. Be warned - most differences will take a sharp eye and careful scrutiny to find. Are you ready for the challenge of Photo Seek? -- Sounds fun, although I wish the images were more interesting to me overall.
Buffalo Games Signature Collection: "La Grande Jatte" by Georges Seurat 1000 pc matte finish 27x20
Buffalo Games Sistine Chapel 2000 pc 38x26
Buffalo Games Written Images Collection: Timber Wolf 1000 pc 27x20 -- Interesting idea, although it doesn't look like they're making that line anymore, and this is the only one that interested me thematically.
Pomegranate Jigsaws -- Absolutely gorgeous high-end art puzzles. I have two of them, although I last did them a few years ago, so my memory is fuzzy. I'm pretty sure they're standard puzzle piece shape and layout -- not as exciting as the really variable stuff that's out there, but a far sight better than Culturenik's "nothing but basics" approach to piece shape.
Pomegranate: Neighborhood Watch by Kathy DeZarn Beynette 300 pc 18x24
Pomegranate: Fairies, 2010, by Michael Hague 300 pc 18x24
Pomegranate: The Addams Family by Charles Addams 300 pc 18x24
Pomegranate: Biosphere: Hydrographers Canyon, 1994 by Alexis Rockman 1000pc 20x25
Pomegranate: Edward Gorey: Frawgge Mfrg Co 1000 pc 20x27 -- I have this one
Pomegranate: Dracula in Dr. Seward’s Library, by Edward Gorey 500-piece 24x18
Pomegranate: Diego Rivera: Detroit Industry 1000 pc 29x20 -- and also this one
Solar System
Da Vinci's World -- I have this one, and really want a lot of these: Scroll down to see all the art themes by artist
Alice In Wonderland, Cheshire Cat - 1000pc Jigsaw Puzzle by Culturenik
Maurice Sendak: Sleeping - 700pc Large Format Jigsaw Puzzle by Heye
Little Red Riding Hood - 500pc Jigsaw Puzzle By Educa
Where the Wild Things Are - 1000pc Jigsaw Puzzle by Culturenik (if it's like the other Culturenik puzzle I've done, they make great designs, but their piece shape is really basic -- given that there are other Sendak puzzles out there from other manufacturers, I'd probably start with them).
Map of the Sky - 1000pc Jigsaw Puzzle by Eurographics
( Read more... )
From my previous post, since I'm using this terminology below:
Piece Shape: I consider the most "Basic" piece shape to be the traditional "two tabs opposite each other" that we tend to imagine as a default. Some puzzles have nothing but these (and are damned hard as a result!) Most, though, have what I'm calling "Standard Varied" shapes -- they're still basically meant to fit within a grid, and have four sides with pretty clear innies and outies in various combinations. That leads to six basic piece shapes, if I'm counting correctly. When I'm working with these kinds of puzzles I tend to sort them first by basic piece shape. Then there are puzzles with "Unusual Varied" pieces that don't fit this basic format, and puzzles with some "Representational" pieces (known as Whimsies in the puzzling world). In my tracking of my puzzles I'm using "Basic/Standard Varied/Unusual Varied/Representational" as my categories.
I'm thinking about and window-shopping puzzles largely because it's hard to sort the wheat from the chaff in finding good puzzles without knowing something about their piece shape and arrangement (since that's a big factor of the enjoyment). It's frustrating to buy an awesome-looking puzzle and discover that it's entirely composed of Basic pieces. Very rarely is this clarified on puzzle-selling sites, so instead I try to take note of which manufacturers use creative dies, and which manufacturers tend to use the kinds of images I enjoy most. Even though specific puzzles below may no longer be available (they tend to go "out of print" quickly), I'll still be better off in finding good stuff overall.
On the puzzle front, I also forgot the other day to note one of the central things I enjoy about doing jigsaw puzzles! I really love the process of having to study a single image so closely and for so long; it gives me practice looking at things in different ways, noting their tiny characteristics, things like that. And I've always been particularly good at most spatial stuff, so I enjoy that element of mentally rotating and matching.
My favorite are puzzles with a lot of intricate detail; I don't like the long slog of trying piece after identical piece in a spot (the worst was a 1000-piece map of the world where the entire ocean was the same exact shade of blue and there was almost no piece shape differentiation). I much prefer having to think more intensely about what that little detail might be, and where it might logically fit. My favorites in that regard are the series of shaped puzzles with all sorts of little thematic details within them.
I just did Hummingbird Garden (Bits & Pieces) yesterday and enjoyed it immensely. Along with the fun detail and shape, it had lots of interesting piece shapes, too, and is a good example of my favorite type of puzzle, as is this Russian Dancer (another one I've done -- I believe it's Bits & Pieces too, although it's out of print).
Fionavar Tapestry Jigsaw Puzzle -- This is one I really enjoyed and found substantially challenging, although I'm not entirely positive I still have it. Sadly, it's also out of print, and I can't find any info on the manufacturer.
A comment from a post long ago, last time I got all puzzle-obsessed: I'm really liking Educa's puzzles, and that they have a lost piece service, and even include a packet of puzzle glue in the box, although I wish they were more creative with piece shape. Ah well; can't have it all.
Puzzle Manufacturers:
This isn't any kind of exhaustive list, just some notes about those I'm aware of, and what I know about them so far:
Bits & Pieces: From the colorful printing to the ultra heavy weight board, to the two piece presentation box, we make our puzzles to the highest standards. We design random cutting dies for more interesting puzzle pieces and rotate the dies to minimize duplication from puzzle to puzzle. -- They're not lying. I love their stuff when I can find images I like. Too bad they seem to mostly do country/nostalgia/cheesy stuff.
Here are a few I find interesting:
Bits & Pieces: Set Of 2 : Comic Chaos 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzles Len Epstein 20x27 Rectangular
Bits & Pieces: Black Bear Mountain 750 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Jack Williams 25x25 Shaped
Bits & Pieces: Wandering From The Den Skunk 750 Piece Shaped Jigsaw Puzzle Russell Cobane 20x27 (all of these shaped animal puzzles are pretty cheesy, but I'll suck it up when it's for my favorite sorts of animals)
Maybe surprisingly I'm not all that fond of Photomosaic jigsaws. I dislike the disconnect between the tiny images I'm trying to match to each other and the overall image itself.
Eurographics
Amazing cosmological, scientific, and artistic puzzle images. Unfortunately, I don't currently know anything about their piece shapes and cuts. Their puzzles also tend toward lots of small items against a solid background, which isn't my ideal sort of image, but on the flip side, those small items are often things like bats and inventors and spiders and musical instruments! If they turn out to have good piece shapes I might as well order stock in the damned company, but if they're boring shapes I'll be much less interested in the future.
Buffalo Games
PhotoSeek 750 Piece Rectangular Puzzles
Side by side they look the same, but look again! The image on the package and the fold out poster have 15 differences from the actual puzzle image. Be warned - most differences will take a sharp eye and careful scrutiny to find. Are you ready for the challenge of Photo Seek? -- Sounds fun, although I wish the images were more interesting to me overall.
Buffalo Games Signature Collection: "La Grande Jatte" by Georges Seurat 1000 pc matte finish 27x20
Buffalo Games Sistine Chapel 2000 pc 38x26
Buffalo Games Written Images Collection: Timber Wolf 1000 pc 27x20 -- Interesting idea, although it doesn't look like they're making that line anymore, and this is the only one that interested me thematically.
Pomegranate Jigsaws -- Absolutely gorgeous high-end art puzzles. I have two of them, although I last did them a few years ago, so my memory is fuzzy. I'm pretty sure they're standard puzzle piece shape and layout -- not as exciting as the really variable stuff that's out there, but a far sight better than Culturenik's "nothing but basics" approach to piece shape.
Pomegranate: Neighborhood Watch by Kathy DeZarn Beynette 300 pc 18x24
Pomegranate: Fairies, 2010, by Michael Hague 300 pc 18x24
Pomegranate: The Addams Family by Charles Addams 300 pc 18x24
Pomegranate: Biosphere: Hydrographers Canyon, 1994 by Alexis Rockman 1000pc 20x25
Pomegranate: Edward Gorey: Frawgge Mfrg Co 1000 pc 20x27 -- I have this one
Pomegranate: Dracula in Dr. Seward’s Library, by Edward Gorey 500-piece 24x18
Pomegranate: Diego Rivera: Detroit Industry 1000 pc 29x20 -- and also this one
Solar System
Da Vinci's World -- I have this one, and really want a lot of these: Scroll down to see all the art themes by artist
Alice In Wonderland, Cheshire Cat - 1000pc Jigsaw Puzzle by Culturenik
Maurice Sendak: Sleeping - 700pc Large Format Jigsaw Puzzle by Heye
Little Red Riding Hood - 500pc Jigsaw Puzzle By Educa
Where the Wild Things Are - 1000pc Jigsaw Puzzle by Culturenik (if it's like the other Culturenik puzzle I've done, they make great designs, but their piece shape is really basic -- given that there are other Sendak puzzles out there from other manufacturers, I'd probably start with them).
Map of the Sky - 1000pc Jigsaw Puzzle by Eurographics
( Read more... )